Churches in the Midst of Polarisation

  • Date
    August 21, 2026 -
    August 25, 2026
    Call for papers closed:
    February 28, 2026
    Registration closed:
    June 26, 2026
  • Venue
    Where:
    Utrecht (Netherlands)
    Adress:
    Protestant Theological University, Jansdam 14, 3512 HB Utrecht
  • Churches in the Midst of Polarisation

    This ecumenical Academic Consultation will critically examine phenomena of polarisation in church and wider society and explore initiatives toward depolarisation. In recent times, political discourse has become increasingly divisive, resulting in palpable tensions and hostility within society. The consultation will address the role of churches and ecumenical organisations in the context of polarising dynamics. It will explore the approaches adopted by these institutions and the manner in which they utilise their positionality. Different types of polarisations, their motives, narratives, dynamics and impact will be examined. This will entail addressing the harm and injustice experienced, and analysing theological responses, and the potential for transformation.

About Consultation

The consultation will discuss the ways in which churches function as colonising or decolonising spaces, and the manner in which theological discourse on gender and identities has been framed in antagonistic terms. The consultation will address the role of symbols and rituals in processes of polarisation and reconciliation. It will also focus on the complex question of truth-seeking amidst conflict and hostility, as a core theological task in the church, as well as in academic and ecumenical spheres. Speakers and participants from a variety of backgrounds and church traditions across Europe will engage in joint analysis and constructive theological reflection.

The following sub-themes will be addressed:

(1) Types of polarisations in churches and in society;
(2) Church as a de/colonising space;
(3) Advocacy or diplomacy: The role of the churches in polarising contexts;
(4) Gender as a de/polarising topic;
(5) Symbol and ritual mediation in reconciling polarisations;
(6) Truth finding in the context of de/polarisation.

Information about the venue, accommodation, and public transport can be found below in section “Venue”.

Statue of Saint Willibrord (†739), “apostle of the Frisians”, on Janskerkhof square in Utrecht.

LIST OF SPONSORS

The consultation is held with the support of the following sponsors:

Catharina Halkes Foundation, C.J. de Vogelstichting, Council of Churches in the Netherlands, Marienburgvereniging, Old Catholic Church of the Netherlands, Oud-Katholiek Seminarie, Pro Religione et Libertate Foundation, Protestant Theological University Utrecht, Renovabis e.V., Stichting Oud-Rustenburg, Stichting Sormani Fonds, Tilburg School of Catholic Theology Utrecht, Unie van Baptistengemeenten, Utrecht Theological University, Vrijzinnige Fondsen, Zonneweelde Foundation

     

               

                        

 

Call for papers

The call for papers has been closed.

Confirmed speakers

Regina Elsner, Sara Gehlin, Sam Goyvaerts, Masiiwa Ragies Gunda, James Hawkey, Alena Höfer, Pantelis Kalaitzidis, Annemarie Mayer, Tim Noble, Mattijs Ploeger, Debora Tonelli, Natallia Vasilevich, Pieter Vos, Edda Wolff

Programme

  • 14:00 – 16:00, registration for the conference (In de Driehoek, Congress & Meeting Center Utrecht)
  • 16:00 – 17:00, opening lecture (In de Driehoek, Congress & Meeting Cente Utrecht)
    • Prof. Dr Simone Sinn, Unmasking Polarisation Discourse: Conceptual Clarifications and Learnings from the Ecumenical Movement
  • 17:15 – 18:45, plenary session I: “Types of Polarisations in Churches and in Society” (In de Driehoek, Congress & Meeting Center Utrecht)
    • Dr Debora Tonelli, The Types of Polarizations in Churches and in Society (Abstract)
    • Prof. Dr Pieter Vos, Moral Polarization and Our Commitment to the Good (Abstract)
    • moderated by Dr Robert Svatoň
  • 18:55, a welcoming word from Bernd Wallet, Archbishop of Utrecht of the Old Catholic Church of the Netherlands followed by a reception sponsored by the Old Catholic Archdiocese of Utrecht (In de Driehoek, Congress & Meeting Center Utrecht)
    • musical performance by Heleen Brüggen (violin), Remi Blokker (violin), and Mia Lodder (viola)
  • 9:00 – 10:30, small papers sessions I (Tilburg School of Catholic Theology Utrecht)
  • 10:30 – 11:00, coffee break (Tilburg School of Catholic Theology Utrecht)
  • 11:00 – 12:30, plenary session II: “Church as a De/colonizing Space” (Catharijneconvent Utrecht)
    • Dr Masiiwa Ragies Gunda, The Paradoxical (Colonial-Decolonial) Church: Toward an Anti-racism, Decolonial and Inclusive Church (Abstract)
    • Dr Alena Höfer, Decolonization between Polarization and Solidarity: Responsibilities and Challenges for Churches Located in the „West“ (Abstract)
    • moderated by Prof. Dr Simone Sinn
  • 12:30, lunch (Tilburg School of Catholic Theology Utrecht)
  • 13:30 – 15:00, plenary session III: “Advocacy or Diplomacy: The Role of the Churches in Polarizing Context” (Catharijneconvent Utrecht)
    • Prof. Dr Tim Noble, Singing the Lord’s Song in a Fractured Land (Abstract)
    • followed by a discussion with: Dr des. Natallia Vasilevich and Dr Stephen Brown
    • moderated by Dr Agnes Slunitschek
  • 15:00 – 15:30, coffee break (outside)
  • 15:30 – 17:00, plenary session IV – public session: “Democracy and the Rule of Law in a Time of Polarization” (Catharijneconvent Utrecht)
    • Prof. Dr Govert J. Buijs (Vrije University), Introduction
    • Ms Eunice Anita-Offerman (Samen Kerk in Nederland, SKIN)
    • Dr Kees van Ekris (Protestant Church in the Netherlands)
    • Prof. Dr Theo de Wit (Tilburg School of Catholic Theology)
    • moderated by Mr Geert van Dartel (chair of the Council of Churches in the Netherlands)
  • 17:00, common prayer (St Catherine’s Cathedral Utrecht)
  • 18:30, dinner (Il Pozzo, Address: Oudegracht a/d Werf 136, Utrecht. For the map, see here)

  • morning, church services
    • Baptist: Buurthuis Burezina (service 10:00)
      • Address: Jeanne d’Arcdreef 1, Utrecht. For a map, see here
    • Greek Orthodox: Church of the Annunciation of the Theotokos (service 9:00)
      • Address: Springweg 89, Utrecht. For a map, see here
    • Mennonite and Lutheran: Doopsgezinde kerk (combined service 10:00)
      • Address: Oudegracht 270, Utrecht. For the map, see here
    • Old Catholic: Oud-Katholieke Gertrudiskathedraal (service 10:00)
      • Address: Willemsplantsoen 2, Utrecht. For the map, see here
    • Reformed (Protestantse Kerk in Nederland): Domkerk (service 10:30)
      • Address: Achter de Dom 1, Utrecht. For the map, see here
    • Roman Catholic: Catharinakathedraal (service 9:30)
      • Address: Lange Nieuwstraat 36, Utrecht. For the map, see here
  • lunch (each person on their own)
  • 14:00 – 17:30, excursions
    • all the participants: Museum Catharijneconvent, Lange Nieuwstraat 38, 3512 PH Utrecht. For the map, see here
    • in groups:
      • Tour of ecclesial Utrecht
      • Utrecht Underground tour
      • Boat tour of the Utrecht rivers
  • dinner (each person on their own)
  • 9:00 – 10:30, plenary session V: “Gender and Human Identities as a De/polarising Topic” (Theological University Utrecht)
    • Prof. Dr Regina Elsner, Gender Essentialism as Theological Problem and Populist Tool in the Catholic Church (Abstract)
    • Dr Pantelis Kalaitzidis, The Theology of “In-Between” and the Role of Women in the Orthodox Church: Orthodox Theology addressing Current Ecclesial Realities (Abstract)
    • Dr Mattijs Ploeger, An Icon of Christ: Seeking Common Ground by Understanding the Ordination of Women from the Perspective of Christology, Soteriology and Sacramental Theology (Abstract)
    • moderated by Prof. Dr Dimitrios Keramidas
    • sponsored by Catharina Halkes Fonds
  • 10:30 – 11:00, coffee break (Theological University Utrecht)
  • 11:00 – 12:30, plenary session VI: “Symbol and Ritual Mediation in Reconciling Polarisations” (Theological University Utrecht)
    • Dr Sam Goyvaerts, The Ambivalence of the Liturgy: Reconciling Ritual, Polarising Practice (Abstract)
    • Dr James Hawkey, “The Sign which stands among the peoples”: Excavating and celebrating the dynamic roots of Christian identity (Abstract)
    • Dr Edda Wolff, Going through the Motions Together: Embodied Practice as a Path to Reconciliation in Polarized Times (Abstract)
    • moderated by Prof. Dr Peter-Ben Smit
  • 12:30, common prayer (Theological University Utrecht)
  • 13:00, lunch (Protestant Theological University)
  • 14:00 – 15:30, small papers sessions II (Protestant Theological University)
  • 15:45 – 16:00, coffee break (Theological University Utrecht)
  • 16:00 – 16:30, news on ecumenical research and events (Theological University Utrecht)
  • 16:30 – 18:30, membership assembly (Theological University Utrecht)
  • 18:45, dinner (KARAF Food & Drinks, Adress: Korte Jansstraat 13-15, Utrecht. For the map, see here)
  • 9:00 – 10:30, small paper sessions III (Theological University Utrecht)
  • 10:30 – 11:00, coffee break (Theological University Utrecht)
  • 11:00 – 12:30, plenary session VII: “Truth Finding in the Context of De/polarisation” (Theological University Utrecht)
    • Dr Sara Gehlin, Truth and Love: Ecumenical Responses to Polarization (Abstract)
    • Prof. Dr Annemarie C. Mayer, Between Unity and Conflict: Ecumenical Reflections on Truth, Dissent, and Community Formation (Abstract)
    • moderated by Prof. Dr Heta Hurskainen
  • 12:30, common prayer (Theological University Utrecht)
  • 13:00, lunch (Theological University Utrecht)